KEY WEST.
BY THE
NUMBERS.
A clearer view of the island’s real estate market. The asking prices, closed sales, pending activity and neighborhood nuances that shape decisions.

IN PERSPECTIVE.Casa Marina / TEAMKAUFELT photography
AN ISLAND
IN DEMAND.
What properties are actually selling for matters more than the headlines. Here’s the Key West MLS perspective on 2026 year-to-date pricing against all of 2025.
Read the periods carefully. The 2026 figures are through September 30, while 2025 covers the full calendar year. These are comparisons of sale-price averages and medians across different periods, not a projected annual rate of appreciation. Source: Florida Keys MLS / MLKAR.
MORE TO CHOOSE.
MORE TO CONSIDER.
October’s MLS comparison puts the choice facing sellers in context: inventory has grown, while the number of closings is below the same month last year.
Active residential listings
Key West MLS city field / October, year over year
Closed residential sales
Key West MLS city field / October, year over year
ONE ISLAND.
MANY MARKETS.
Compare how neighborhoods are valued across Key West. These are modeled typical values, not recent closed-sale averages for an individual street or property.
Zillow Home Value Index / September 2026
Highest modeled value first · Choose a neighborhood to explore

YOUR HOME ISN’T
THE AVERAGE.
Buyers don’t purchase a market average. They purchase a home, a street, a lifestyle. We’ll show you how your property compares and what it takes to stand apart.
Let’s talk about your homeNOT JUST THE HEADLINE.
Published snapshot verified November 16, 2026. The 53 pending/under-contract figure is from Redfin’s Key West area pending search, which also includes some nearby island and Stock Island properties; it is not the city-only Florida Keys MLS pending count. Redfin’s live destination changes as listings update. Active inventory (369), days on market (119) and median asking price per square foot ($945) are from Realtor.com’s October 2026 Key West overview. October sales (23) and the 2025/2026 inventory and closing comparisons use the published FlexMLS Key West city comparison. Full-year 2025 and Jan–Sep 2026 closed-price benchmarks use the MLKAR Florida Keys MLS price reports. Neighborhood typical values are from Zillow Research’s September 2026 Key West neighborhood figures. Different sources use different definitions, coverage and update schedules; counts should not be summed or treated as equivalent. This page is a verified editorial market snapshot, not an automated real-time MLS feed.

