TEAMKAUFELT

  • Menu
  • Home
  • Listings
    • Active
    • Sold
    • Buyers
      • A Buyer’s Guide to Closing Costs
      • Florida Mortgage Calculator
    • Sellers
      • Net Sheet Calculator
      • Marketing Plan
      • Property Analysis
  • Search
    • Simple MLS Search
    • Advanced Search
    • By Neighborhood
      • Old Town
      • The Meadows
      • Casa Marina
      • Mid Town
      • New Town
      • Key Haven
      • Stock Island
      • Big Coppitt
      • Sugarloaf
    • By Price
      • $500,000 – $1 Million
      • $1-2 Million
      • $2-3 Million
      • $3 Million and Above
  • Key West Real Estate Videos
  • Testimonials
  • Team Kaufelt
    • Meet the Team
    • Lynn Kaufelt
    • Jackson Kaufelt
  • The Kaufelt Report
  • Contact
  • Marketing Brochure
  • fb
  • ig
  • yt

Historic Key West Commercial Real Estate: The Coffee Mill

Locals and tourists alike know this landmark property located just off Truman Avenue as The Coffee Mill. Built prior to 1907, the property was home to an active coffee bean processing plant until the 1950’s. In recent years, the building was famously home to one of Key West’s most popular dance studios.

The current owners have done extensive renovations to update the space to today’s standards while maintaining many of the historical features of the property. Updates include a complete modernization of the electrical and plumbing systems, new central A/C and ductwork, masterful restoration of the original hardwood floors, and the construction of private treatment rooms and a business office — all while preserving the original exterior and character of the building.

The MLS listing says describes the property this way: “Features include multiple skylights, a period correct metal shingle roof, beautiful historic arched transom windows salvaged from Henry Flagler’s Casa Marina hotel, and an updated bathroom. The property is up to current building code and ADA compliant, and was awarded a Ceramic Star for historic preservation and a Certificate of Excellence by The Historic Florida Keys Foundation. The Coffee Mill has been a staple in Old Town for over 100 years and continues to be an important part of the historic district.”

CLICK HERE to view the Key West MLS listing for 916 Pohalski Street, offered for sale at $1,000,000. Please call or text, Damian Vantriglia, 305.741.9411 to schedule a private showing of this very rare commercial real estate opportunity in the Historic District of Old Town, Key West. View the full listing, 3D tour, and more: https://www.teamkaufelt.com/

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Team Kaufelt📍Key West (@teamkaufelt)

COFFEE MILL WEB-6
COFFEE MILL WEB-24
COFFEE MILL WEB-16
COFFEE MILL WEB-11
COFFEE MILL WEB-20
COFFEE MILL WEB-25
the coffee mill 1958

Posted in: All Posts, Real Estate Tagged: Commercial real estate, Historic, Key West, property for sale

RECENTLY SOLD

Sold
Residential1995000

419 Simonton Street c 621400

419 Simonton Street c
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 2Beds
  • 3Baths
  • 1,409Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential2170000

1308 Reynolds Street 618735

1308 Reynolds Street
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 3Beds
  • 3Baths
  • 1,662Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential2868000

901 Johnson Street 618506

901 Johnson Street
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 3Beds
  • 4Baths
  • 2,507Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential1325000

419 Simonton Street A 618250

419 Simonton Street A
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 2Beds
  • 3Baths
  • 1,082Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential2,070,000

419 Simonton Street C 618252

419 Simonton Street C
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 2Beds
  • 3Baths
  • 1,409Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential825000

17245 Jamaica Lane, Sugarloaf Shores, FL | MLS# 617093

17245 Jamaica Lane
Sugarloaf, Florida 33042

  • 3Beds
  • 2Baths
  • 1,248Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential3800000

Key West Luxury Homes | 802 Southard Street, Key West, FL | MLS# 614646

802 Southard Street
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 4Beds
  • 5Baths
  • 2,310Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential$1,250,000

804 Ashe Street, Key West, FL | MLS# 612463

804 Ashe Street
KEY WEST, Florida 33040

  • 2Beds
  • 2Baths
  • 1,046Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential4000000

Key West Luxury Homes | 810 Eisenhower Drive, Key West, FL | MLS# 614269

810 Eisenhower Drive
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 4Beds
  • 5Baths
  • 2,177Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential1675000

1211 Olivia Street, Key West, FL | MLS# 612462

1211 Olivia Street
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 4Beds
  • 2Baths
  • 1,714Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential1650000

822 Georgia Street, Key West, FL | MLS# 612933

822 Georgia Street
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 3Beds
  • 3Baths
  • 1,755Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential2175000

711 Ashe Street, Key West, FL | MLS# 612932

711 Ashe Street
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 2Beds
  • 2Baths
  • 1,058Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential1250000

804 Ashe Street, Key West, FL | MLS# 612463

804 Ashe Street
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 2Beds
  • 2Baths
  • 1,046Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential1892500

3731 Eagle Avenue, Key West, FL | MLS# 612305

3731 Eagle Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 3Beds
  • 3Baths
  • 2,085Sq ft
View Listing
Sold
Residential1625000

715 Thomas Street, Key West, FL | MLS #611301

715 Thomas Street
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 2Beds
  • 2Baths
  • 1,980Sq ft
View Listing

FEATURED LISTINGS

Active
Residential$4,700,000

1014 Flagler Avenue | Casa Marina, Key West | MLS 618577

1014 Flagler Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 3Beds
  • 4Baths
  • 3,104Sq ft
View Listing
Active
Residential$1,235,000

738 Olivia Street 621972

738 Olivia Street
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 1Beds
  • 2Baths
  • 767Sq ft
View Listing
Active
Residential$1,895,000

905 Grinnell Street 621807

905 Grinnell Street
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 8Beds
  • 4Baths
  • 3,383Sq ft
View Listing
Active
Residential$4,650,000

1028 Flagler Avenue 621710

1028 Flagler Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 4Beds
  • 5Baths
  • 3,589Sq ft
View Listing
Active
Residential$1,095,000

1503 Atlantic Boulevard 620612

1503 Atlantic Boulevard
Key West, Florida 33040

  • 4Beds
  • 5Baths
  • 2,750Sq ft
View Listing
A Key West original. 1014 Flagler Avenue is a storied Casa Marina residence shaped by legendary Key West developer David Wolkowsky and set behind privacy walls on an exceptional 11,730-square-foot corner double lot. Some homes are built. Others are authored. At its center: 40 feet of pool, surrounded by mature tropical landscaping and hardscape by Craig Reynolds Landscape Architecture, creating the feel of a private compound hidden in plain sight. Inside, the scale shifts again with 22-foot ceilings, walls of glass, 10-foot doors and sliders, custom teak, and a dramatic floor-to-ceiling library. The main residence offers two bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths, anchored by a chef's kitchen and expansive indoor-outdoor living. Extensive updates include new systems and impact-rated windows and doors. A completely separate one-bedroom guest house adds its own kitchen, laundry and private garden. 3 bedrooms. 3.5 baths. 3,104 square feet. 11,730 square feet of land. 40 feet of pool. In a market full of beautiful houses, 1014 Flagler offers something harder to replicate: a point of view. $4,700,000 Active

1014 Flagler Avenue Key West, Florida

3 Beds 4 Baths 3,104 SqFt

A CASA MARINA ORIGINAL.Some houses capture a moment in time. Others seem to have understood, from the beginning, what makes Key West such an extraordinary place to live.Built in 1958, 1028 Flagler Avenue is a striking example of tropical mid-century modern architecture, set within a private three-building compound on 11,586 square feet in Casa Marina, one of the island's most distinguished neighborhoods.Behind substantial privacy walls lies a world of its own. Winding pathways lead through lush native and tropical gardens that seem borrowed from a movie, connecting the main residence, separate two-bedroom guest quarters, and detached garage/workshop. Mature palms, flowering gardens, shaded terraces, and a custom swimming pool create an extraordinary sense of seclusion.Inside, clean architectural lines, high ceilings, and generous proportions celebrate indoor-outdoor living. Expansive living and dining areas, a library, and a separate study offer room to gather or retreat. Impact-rated windows and doors provide modern peace of mind without sacrificing the home's character.The guest quarters include their own living area and kitchen, ideal for family and visitors. Together, the three buildings offer 3,589 square feet of combined enclosed space: 3,173 square feet of living area plus a 416-square-foot garage/workshop. Covered outdoor dining, an outdoor kitchen, and abundant off-street parking make this compound as practical as it is beautiful.Just two blocks from Higgs Beach and the Atlantic Ocean, with White Street Pier, waterfront parks, tennis, pickleball, and some of Key West's best-loved restaurants close at hand. Old Town is minutes away, yet the privacy and tranquility of Casa Marina remain entirely your own. $4,650,000 Active

1028 Flagler Avenue Key West, Florida

4 Beds 5 Baths 3,589 SqFt

A former church with a practical second calling. At 905 Grinnell Street, four occupied residences carry monthly rents totaling $11,249. There is also off-street parking--a feature whose virtues need little explanation to anyone acquainted with Old Town.The building retains its distinctive character while accommodating a three-bedroom residence, two two-bedroom residences, and a studio, each with one bathroom. Separate entrances and outdoor spaces lend the apartments a measure of independence. Together, they comprise approximately 3,383 square feet on a 5,737-square-foot lot.Concrete-block construction, a metal roof, and a location in the X-500 flood zone supply the practical details. The surrounding Historic District supplies the rest: neighborhood restaurants, shops, and Duval Street within walking distance.Offered at $1,895,000, with tenants in place and an established rental history. Rental and operating statements are available for those who prefer to read beyond the photographs. $1,895,000 Active

905 Grinnell Street Key West, Florida

8 Beds 4 Baths 3,383 SqFt

SAY HELLO TO THE KEY LIME COTTAGE. A slice of Key West, with more room than you'd expect.With lime-green siding, white trim, and a blue front door, 738 Olivia Street has a personality that carries beyond the curb. Set in the X flood zone in Old Town, this historic Conch cottage pairs classic character with two bonus spaces and indoor-outdoor living.Framed by palms, a proper Key West front porch invites coffee, conversation, and watching the world go by. You may leave later than intended.Inside, cathedral ceilings give the living space height and presence. The kitchen features quartz countertops, custom wood cabinetry, and stainless steel appliances. Impact windows and doors and mini-split cooling add comfort. Listed as one bedroom, the cottage lives well beyond its bedroom count, with a ladder-accessed sleeping loft and detached cabana providing two distinct bonus spaces.French doors open to a large covered lanai for al fresco dining or an afternoon with nowhere else to be. Living flows into the lush tropical courtyard, making the outdoors another room of the house.The cabana offers bonus space for a studio, workspace, or potential sleeping retreat, with an outdoor shower, half bath, and refrigerator nearby. For investors, the main bedroom and two bonus spaces offer potential for three separate sleeping areas, broadening rental appeal.A broad, rarely used private landscaped driveway beside the home and an expansive tropical private parking lot behind it create unusual separation. In Old Town, where cottages often stand just feet apart, this breathing room is a quiet luxury. Parking accommodates a large vehicle and potentially a moped or small golf cart in front or behind it.Duval Street is three blocks away, with Fort Zachary Taylor State Park, Higgs and Smathers beaches, restaurants, and grocery stores within biking distance. Enough nearby to fill the day. A very good porch if you decide otherwise. $1,235,000 Active

738 Olivia Street Key West, Florida

1 Beds 2 Baths 767 SqFt 0.05 Acres

THIS IS THE PLAY. Big lot. Big upside. Atlantic Boulevard address. 1503 Atlantic Boulevard brings together the pieces that matter most in Key West: land, location, pool, and multi-unit flexibility.Atlantic Boulevard has only a handful of true residential opportunities, and this one brings the rare combination of land, pool, and multi-unit upside. Set on an approximately 8,050 square foot lot, this Atlantic-side property offers roughly 2,750 square feet of living area with a flexible multi-unit configuration and a concrete pool anchoring the outdoor space. The existing home would benefit from a major renovation and thoughtful updating for today's standards, creating a compelling opportunity for an investor, owner-user, or buyer with vision. In a market where land is the luxury, the lot itself is a major part of the story. The scale, pool, and layout create the foundation for a refreshed tropical compound, income-producing retreat, or reimagined Key West residence. Located along Atlantic Boulevard, the property is close to beaches, Old Town, Casa Marina, schools, dining, and the everyday ease that makes island living so desirable. Whether held as a long-term income property or transformed into something more polished, 1503 Atlantic Boulevard offers the kind of upside that is increasingly hard to find in Key West. $1,095,000 Active

1503 Atlantic Boulevard Key West, Florida

4 Beds 5 Baths 2,750 SqFt 0.18 Acres

A Key West Antiquity. A fresh point of view.The story of 921 Angela Street reaches into Key West's cigar-making past. The address appears in the city's 1906 directory as the residence of cigar maker Claude Johnson--a connection to the craftsmen who helped shape the island.Today, Dade County pine walls and floors, high ceilings, and a front porch that participates in the neighborhood carry that Old Town character forward.Set in the X-500 flood zone within Key West's Historic District, this two-bedroom, two-bath cottage offers the opportunity for thoughtful renovation--a chance to bring the home into the present while preserving its enduring appeal. Downstairs, the living area, kitchen, and guest bedroom establish a straightforward layout. Upstairs, the primary suite has its own bath and closet.Outside, privacy fencing and mature tropical landscaping frame a backyard ready for your own vision. The rear deck offers space for outdoor dining and quiet afternoons, with the possibility of a cocktail pool, subject to space, permitting, and required approvals.Walk to neighborhood restaurants, galleries, and world-famous Duval Street, or bicycle to the island's beaches and parks. Mornings on the porch. Afternoons by the water. A tropical retreat shaped around the way you want to live.An Old Town original, ready for a little imagination and a thoughtful hand. $895,000 Active Under Contract

921 Angela Street Key West, Florida

2 Beds 2 Baths 1,092 SqFt

MARKETING KIT

ABOUT US

TEAMKAUFELT is proud to be recognized as the #1 active real estate team in Key West per the MLS for 2022 and 2023. In a year marked by extraordinary shifts in the marketplace we worked together to provide local expertise, real estate knowledge, and unmatched responsiveness.

SOCIAL MEDIA

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • youtube.com/channel/UCQnxsfzBqO9rlcOalc8ctbQ?sub_confirmation=1
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

GET IN TOUCH

Lynn Kaufelt | 305.923.4276
Jackson Kaufelt | 305.393.1267
Ethan Perloff | 540.450.7315

teamk@trumanandcompany.com
www.teamkaufelt.com
1205 Truman Avenue | Key West, FL 33040

Truman & Co. logo
Leading Real Estate Companies of the World
<

TEAM KAUFELT

Truman & Company

1205 Truman Avenue
Key West, FL 33040
Mobile: 305.393.1267
Office: 305.292.2244
teamkaufelt@trumanandcompany.com
>
TEAMKAUFELTLogo Header Menu
Right Menu Icon
  • Home
  • Listings
    • Active
    • Sold
    • Buyers
      • A Buyer’s Guide to Closing Costs
      • Florida Mortgage Calculator
    • Sellers
      • Net Sheet Calculator
      • Marketing Plan
      • Property Analysis
  • Search
    • Simple MLS Search
    • Advanced Search
    • By Neighborhood
      • Old Town
      • The Meadows
      • Casa Marina
      • Mid Town
      • New Town
      • Key Haven
      • Stock Island
      • Big Coppitt
      • Sugarloaf
    • By Price
      • $500,000 – $1 Million
      • $1-2 Million
      • $2-3 Million
      • $3 Million and Above
  • Key West Real Estate Videos
  • Testimonials
  • Team Kaufelt
    • Meet the Team
    • Lynn Kaufelt
    • Jackson Kaufelt
  • The Kaufelt Report
  • Contact
  • Marketing Brochure
  • fb
  • ig
  • yt
Loading Comments...

You must be logged in to post a comment.